How not to freeze and burn in winter in a tent: tips from fishermen. How to organize the heating of the tent: step by step instructions. Tents with a stove. Tourist Tent Heater

Fishermen are more often worried low temperatures overboard, which are very difficult to deal with when fishing. A winter suit with a fleece, mittens with fur, felt boots and even special thermal underwear as for astronauts it is unlikely that they will significantly help even in a 20-degree frost. Therefore, in order not to die on ice, in a piercing wind, additional means of heating are simply necessary.

The thought immediately comes to mind mobile home or tent, it is very difficult to do without it on an open reservoir in the winter and you can freeze in a matter of minutes. Stiff legs and arms do not at all add sympathy to winter fishing. Plus, freezing long time very harmful to health. Therefore, choosing a good tent for winter fishing will guarantee that you will not survive in the forest in winter, but turn winter fishing into a comfortable and exciting experience.

Setting up a tent for winter fishing

First thing to do before setting up a tent for ice fishing- this is to determine which side the wind is blowing from and position the tent so that the entrance and ventilation holes go to opposite side. Thanks to this, the tent will be protected from direct penetration of cold air and will be more stable.

Being inside the tent, the angler must leave open at least one air vent no matter how hard the frost is. Otherwise, condensation will quickly form inside the tent, which will lead to more cooling. When setting up a tent for winter fishing, be sure to make sure that it the lower part was covered with snow. In this case, you will not only insulate it, but also give it greater stability. You can freeze the lower part to the ice, but just be careful when removing the tent later.

Heating tent for winter fishing

One winter tent winter fishing will be small and very inefficient in terms of keeping warm. There are different ways to get out of this situation. Usually anglers use:

• candles for heating tents for winter fishing

Candles for heating a tent for ice fishing are the most economical and compact way, they are cheap and take up little space. Wax or paraffin candles give off enough heat when burned to keep the temperature inside the tent, but only up to a certain temperature outside. But from experience it is known that even at minus 15 on the street, this wax option does not save much. Plus, it is possible for a fishing line to get on fire from a candle.

• gas stoves for ice fishing

For lovers of winter fishing, special heaters are produced. They differ in fuel, due to which the tent is heated, as well as in the working volume. Some copies work without refueling for two to three hours, others a little longer. Most often, these heaters run on gas fuel. The most popular means of gas equipment is a cylinder with a tile. The tile gives off much more heat, quickly warms up the tent space, but it should be remembered that the tile with a balloon is rather bulky equipment.

• dry fuel for heating the tent on winter fishing

Other anglers use dry fuel heaters to heat their tents while ice fishing. You can easily make such a heating pad yourself. To do this, in an ordinary tin, we make holes for air to enter and the oven is ready. It is suitable for both heating the tent and for heating food. But dry fuel emits a lot of unpleasant odors, and if you burn it, for example, all night, you can get poisoned and even lose consciousness. Therefore, it is not recommended to use this method of heating.

How to heat a tent for winter fishing

In addition to the aforementioned methods, many fishermen use a primus stove to heat their scarves during winter fishing. Some fishermen, going on a trip by car, take cast-iron stoves for the tent. They run on either gas or wood. And in order not to burn out, a pipe is attached to the furnace, which goes out into the street. Such a stove is heated all night long, the temperature in the tent will be very comfortable.

It is extremely important to remember safety when ice fishing! Heated dry tents ignite easily from the slightest spark or overheating of heaters, be very careful!

How to insulate a tent for winter fishing

However, warming up the tent is half the battle, you still need to keep it warm in it. To keep warm, some manufacturers make double-walled tents. In such designs it is noticeably warmer. But if you have the most common scarf, then you can try to upgrade it. You can use any non-toxic building material intended for hydrothermal and noise insulation. This material can be used to cover the floor in a tent, keeping a place for holes, then the cold from the ice will enter the house much less. Also from this material you can make capes on the tent in the form of caps. And then a wonderful winter fishing for pike, burbot, bream, carp, perch, carp will be provided to you!

For those who are really interested in the topic, we suggest watching a video about heating tents for winter fishing.

Video - winter fishing tent heating

Happy winter fishing and remember to be safe on the ice and in a heated tent!

Heating a winter tent is an important topic. Both the possibility of fishing in the cold season and its result directly depend on the heat inside the fishing shelter. In this review article, we tried to collect all the known options for heating a tent for winter fishing - with the obligatory indication of the disadvantages and advantages of each of them. With all that, we have tested and evaluated some of the methods personally, which will also be mentioned in the following story.

Solid fuel mini oven

Long gone are the days when there were no modern portable gas stoves, and stoves were a rarity. Fishermen at that time used home-made mini-stoves to heat winter tents - welded from sheet iron, or hastily welded from some metal containers. Such stoves usually ran on wood, although other solid fuels, such as coal, could also be used.

One of my railway acquaintances, in the world an avid bream hunter, in the late 80s regularly fished in our surrounding water bodies - the Revdinsky city pond and. He heated his tent with a homemade coal stove. According to his reviews - "it was so hot that he was sitting in a T-shirt."

There were a great many designs of these stoves. Here, as they say - who was much for what. However, the principle was the same everywhere - a firebox, a stand (so that the ice does not melt) and a chimney pipe that went out through a special hole in the tent wall, edged with non-combustible material like fiberglass. In other words, a miniature potbelly stove.

Nowadays, mini-stoves have been superseded by more efficient and compact devices for heating a tent. However, this does not mean at all that no one now heats a tent with firewood. In rural areas, especially in some villages far from cities, this is still a very popular method, sometimes the only possible one.

• Pros: cheap or free fuel, good calorific value.
• Minuses: cumbersome design, complete uselessness in the absence of firewood in the place of fishing, the need for in large numbers fuel (the aforementioned acquaintance dragged an average bucket of coal for fishing). In addition, I had to periodically throw firewood into the stove, distracting from fishing.

Primus

With the advent of "lights", "bumblebees" and other gasoline burners, wood stoves began to gradually fade into the background. And for quite a long period of time, the fishing tents were heated with stoves. Even now, there are still many adherents of this method.

On several fishing trips, I had a chance to use the rather mass-produced primus stove "Dastan". I will say this: power. This is probably the warmest way to heat a winter tent, and even the preliminary fuss with kindling the stove, as well as some stink of fuel, does not overshadow this fact.

• Pros: compactness, excellent calorific value.
• Minuses: difficulty in use. And to this day there are legends about the "reliability" of stoves, but here - again - it all depends on the manufacturer, the specific model and the specific product. For example, imported primus stoves are quite well made, like some Soviet ones.

Oil burners (multi-fuel)

In fact, these are the same stoves, only a high-tech version. They are deprived of most of the shortcomings of the “bumblebees”, you can also use any diffusers-afterburners with them (which you can’t put on a regular stove), thereby increasing their efficiency.

• Pros: excellent calorific value, versatility in terms of fuel used.
• Minuses: high price.

Gas hob with 5 liter propane tank

Another old proven method of heating a tent, which is still in full use today. If the balloon is left outside, the tile itself takes up very little space.

One of my acquaintances, a fisherman, has been using such tiles for a long time, and it doesn’t blow in his mustache.

• Pros: long operation from one filling, excellent calorific value (models existing on the market are very powerful), greater reliability and safety compared to stoves.
• Minuses: the bulkiness of the structure and its increased weight, the likelihood of gas freezing in severe frosts (especially if the cylinder was not pure propane, but its mixture with other gases).

Gas stove or heater on disposable cylinders

Appeared relatively recently and gained good popularity. They could even supplant other methods of heating tents, if not for one significant drawback, which is discussed below.

The author of this article actively uses a gas heater (power of the order of a kilowatt) for winter fishing, and knows fishermen who are also heated by such equipment. Previously, I had to use tiles several times - they heat quite well.

This category could also include gas lamps However, their calorific value leaves much to be desired, so if they are suitable for heating a winter tent, then only during mild cold weather.

• Pros: compactness, you can also add affordable and relatively inexpensive fuel here.
• Minuses: the main one is the probability of gas freezing already in light frosts (thin-walled cartridges are designed for gas mixtures with a lower vapor pressure, evaporating at higher temperatures). How to deal with this - it is written in. In addition, some tiles and heaters are very limited in power, which somewhat reduces their effectiveness during severe frosts.

Paraffin candles

The power of one candle is about 40 watts / hour. Not such a small number. It turns out that four dozen candles may well compete in terms of heat generated with a portable gas heater.

The author of these lines more than once had to heat the fishing tent with ordinary candles. It is safe to say that this method works great in mild frosts with the right number of candles: the holes do not freeze, and it is quite comfortable in the tent.

• Pros: lighting, simplicity, no need for additional equipment.
• Minuses: low power (than stronger frost- the more candles you need).

Dry fuel

Some types of dry fuel, for example, "dry alcohol" tablets, burn for 10-15 minutes without soot and odor. The specific heat of combustion of this fuel is 30 mJ / kg, which corresponds to 8.3 kilowatts. You can go further and calculate the "power" of one tablet. It is approximately 332-498 W / h. Therefore, dry fuel can be used to heat a winter tent.

A fisherman friend of mine once had a chance to heat a tent with dry fuel while winter fishing (on the river), and not just anyhow - but during an overnight stay. I took quite a few tablets with me - several packages, but it took only three to heat. It was not possible to freeze at that night (considering that outside the thermometer did not fall below -10°C). How to sleep well.

• Pros: high calorific value, ease of use.
• Minuses: the need to be distracted every 15-20 minutes to ignite a new pill. It is possible that a special stove could solve this problem, where several tablets could be loaded at once, and then “stretch” the process of their combustion, limiting the supply of oxygen. However, so far no one has invented it.

Alcohol

The specific heat of combustion of alcohol is 27 mJ/kg, which is almost two times less than that of natural gas, but it is quite enough to use alcohol as a fuel for a tent heater. And some fishermen - who have constant access to supplies of this substance - do just that, using homemade tin can spirit lamps as a heater. Nevertheless, most anglers consider this approach to be unreasonably wasteful, if not sacrilegious, and it is understandable for what reason.

• Pros: good calorific value.
• Minuses: relatively high cost of fuel, or difficulty in acquiring it.

The angler himself

The human body, it turns out, can also be considered as a heater. At rest, it produces an average of 60 watts of heat per hour. Therefore, with a small "minus" - after setting up the tent - the holes usually stop freezing, and a heater is not required.

• Pros: nothing extra is needed.
• Minuses: small power, sufficient only for "warm" winter weather.

Sun

To some, this item will seem even more frivolous, but in fact the sun's rays have a very high calorific potential. Especially when you consider the fact that during the winter in our hemisphere, the Earth is at its very close range from the sun.

On clear windless days - even in 30-degree frosts - you can notice the appearance of icicles on dark objects partially covered with snow. This is due to the fact that the sun heats them up to a low positive temperature, at which the snow begins to melt. And the temperature difference here clearly exceeds 30 degrees, which is quite a lot.

The sun also warms up the fisherman's tent a little, though with a very tiny part of the heat of its rays. And the lion's share of this heat is dissipated into the external space - due to reflection from the fabric and cooling it with cold air constantly circulating outside.

Somehow it is necessary to direct the solar heat inside the tent, but at the same time minimize its return to the outside. The prospects for this method of heating are obvious, and it is quite feasible even with modern technologies. But so far, there are no practical developments in this direction. Who will take care of it?

• Pros: free energy.
• Minuses: useless in cloudy weather and at night. Well, as mentioned above - at the moment, the full use of solar heat to heat a winter tent is just a theory. In practice, however, it turns out that sunny weather we have small bonus- five degrees to the main source of heating, whether it be a stove, stove, burner, or a heater.

Overnight in a tent is great. But when it's cold outside, it requires special preparation, especially if children are taking part in the hike. Today we will find out what are the ways to heat the tent in the cold season. Let's start with the simplest and finish with the most technologically advanced and costly.

Clothes and sleeping bag

An important role in the issue of heating is played by the tourist's clothing, his and the mattress. If all these attributes are chosen correctly and performed with high quality, then they will be enough to comfortably spend the night in the autumn forest. However, with the advent of real cold weather, such heat will not be enough. There will also be little of it for children, and there are two reasons for this. First, children get colder. And secondly, they like to toss and turn and open up in a dream. Therefore, it is important to heat the entire tent.

By the way, if you spend the night in and in principle, and in any other case, try to make sure that the parts of your body are in contact with each other as much as possible. At the very least, take your hands out of your sleeves. The principle of mittens works here, which, as you know, warms (or it would be more correct to say, retains body heat) much more efficiently than a glove. To keep the sleeping bag warmer before the bitter cold sets in, a simple bottle of hot water, which you need to take with you in a bag. Get a kind of heating pad.

Candles

The second easiest way is to heat the tent with candles. It is suitable in the fall, when you need to slightly warm it up, but in winter, candles will not be enough. Live fire in a tent is very dangerous, so it can only be used in two cases. The first is when you are awake and can follow the burning of the candle and its vertical position. Usually candles are used by winter fishing enthusiasts who put up a tent not at all for sleeping, but for protection from wind and precipitation. Well, the second case is when the candle is in a safe burner. The design of such a burner was invented by tourists. You just need to take a metal shell from an old thermos flask and put a candle in it. Such a burner has a number of advantages. Firstly, if the thermos falls, the candle will remain in it and will not cause harm. Secondly, the candle heats the thermos, which means that the heat transfer surface increases several times.

stones

Heating the tent with stone / stones is an old method, distinguished by its simplicity and reliability. It is suitable for more severe cold weather than the previous two. But here, as in everything, there are nuances.

If you just take a heated stone and bring it into the tent, it will be hot, but not for long. Literally in an hour the stone will cool down and the cold will come again. The first way to increase the cooling time of the stone is to place it in a pot and close the lid. Such a simple manipulation will provide heating of the tent for three hours, but this is not enough for a comfortable sleep. It is necessary to slow down the heat transfer of the stone so that it remains hot for at least 6-8 hours. For this purpose, simple aluminum foil is used. It is non-flammable, lightweight and very compact. If you wrap the stone in several layers of foil, it will cool much more slowly and will not create stuffiness in the first hours of cooling. Heat will be retained due to the air gap between the layers. If you feel that the tent has become cold, just remove one layer of foil.

A red-hot stone can burn through the bottom of the tent, so it is placed in a pot or pan. It is good if the stone gets stuck in the socket of the container and does not heat up its bottom. Otherwise, a wooden plank should be placed under the pan. Another important nuance: do not heat the stone too intensely in the fire. Due to a sharp temperature drop on the surface and inside, it may crack.

A canister of hot water also works like a stone. Only heat transfer occurs much faster.

Ground heating

Now we will learn how to heat a tent on a hike in severe cold weather. An old and reliable way is to put up a tent in the place of a fire. There are two options here. The first takes more time and energy. To begin with, at the place where the tent will be set up in the future, you need to remove the sod. Dig should be to a depth of 20 centimeters. Then a huge fire with wide logs is lit in this pit. The main goal at this stage is to dry and warm the earth, as well as to get large coals. When the coals are ready, they are evenly distributed over the pit and covered with a 7-10 cm layer of earth. It is important that the ground is dry. If there is none, you need to use the second method below. Dry grass or spruce branches are laid on the ground, and a tent is placed on top. The tent is heated throughout the night.

The second option is less energy intensive. In this case, there is no need to dig a hole. All that needs to be done is to kindle a large fire, and when it burns out, carefully remove the coals to the side. On the ground hot from the fire, spruce branches are laid and a tent is put up.

Heating a tent with a pipe

Let's move on to more sophisticated and technological methods. To bring this idea to life, you need to take 5-6 meters of duralumin pipe with you on a hike. It can be divided into meter lengths for easy transportation. It is even better to take segments of different diameters and fold them into each other. But do not forget about the seal at the joints, otherwise all the heat will go into the air. The weight of such a set will not be significant at all.

So, for starters, a fire is kindled a few meters from the entrance to the tent. The pipe is placed on the fire in such a way that one end goes into the tent, and the other protrudes beyond the flame so that smoke does not get into it. The end of the pipe that goes into the tent should be 1.5 meters higher than the second end. This design works very simply: cold air, entering the pipe, heats up and rises, getting into the tent. The steeper the slope of the pipe, the more air will circulate. And the closer the fire is to the tent, the hotter this air will become.

To provide yourself with efficient heating, you can go further and make two pits, as in the figure below. The first is needed to protect the tent from fire, and the second - to ensure good airflow. If the tent is too hot, you can simply close the chimney.

Heating a tent with the above methods requires energy and time. In conditions when every day you move to a new place and get very tired, this is quite inconvenient. It is also uncomfortable if there are children in the hiking group. Therefore, many prefer to use modern technologies. We will talk about them below.

Gas heater

Heater with a metal working fluid

Such a camping heater can be either an attachment to a gas primus stove or an independent device. The first option requires special care, because its hot surface, as a rule, is not protected. Therefore, leaving such a heater overnight is not recommended.

Independent designs are more acceptable for night heating of the tent. They are more stable on the surface and have protection of the danger zone from objects from the outside. Such heaters may have one or two independent burners. Thanks to the parabolic reflector (reflector) from the working fluid can be directed in the right direction. On sale there are a lot of such heaters, both foreign and domestic production. The advantages of the device are simplicity of design, low cost, safety. Cons - low return, insufficient efficiency.

Heater with ceramic working medium

A portable heater of this type has a stronger heat dissipation, and therefore, it is more economical. The combustion process takes place on the surface of a ceramic plate that has a shape similar to a honeycomb. Heat is removed much more efficiently than with an open flame. Up to 50% of the combustion energy is converted into thermal radiation. The advantages of ceramic burners are efficiency, compactness, unpretentiousness, a little carbon monoxide is released during operation, directional action. Unfortunately, domestic heaters lose to imported ones on all fronts.

Gasoline Tent Heater

Gasoline heaters work on the same principle as gas heaters. The main advantages of such products are availability and the ability to work in any weather. The gas burner for heating the tent at a temperature of -5 degrees and below starts to act up. However, along with all the advantages, gasoline heaters also have significant disadvantages. The main one is danger. If not used correctly, the balloon can do much harm. And the fuel itself - gasoline - requires careful transportation.

Safety precautions when working with gas and gasoline heaters

Using these products in a tent, it is worth Special attention pay attention to the following safety rules:

1. There must be at least a little ventilation in the tent to remove combustion products.

2. The heater for the tent should be at least half a meter away from the wall.

4. It is desirable to have sleeping area at a height of up to 25 cm from the floor. Carbon monoxide is heavier than air, so it accumulates at the bottom.

5. Only special cylinders are suitable for use in a tent, which are equipped with protective automation. It blocks the gas supply if the burner goes out or overheats. Also, the cylinder must have a certificate allowing its use in residential premises.

6. The heater must be installed on a non-combustible support with an area exceeding the area of ​​the burner by at least 30%.

Well, the most effective way to heat a tent is to put a potbelly stove in it. This is the method used in army tents. Of course, it has more modest dimensions than the army, but the essence is the same. This method of heating is not suitable for a small tent. You will have to tinker with the stove, but the result will be more than worthy. There are few such products on the market, but they still exist. And some even adapt to gas and gasoline. The stove, as a rule, comes with a collapsible chimney. It is made of light metal and does not weigh much. The advantages of the stove - it gives a lot of heat, has a simple but reliable design of the hood, is inexpensive, does not require refueling.

Conclusion

Today we figured out how to heat a tent on a camping trip. There are many ways to make camping life more comfortable and safer, from the use of simple candles to full-fledged stoves. Which one to choose from this variety depends on the season, the place of rest, the composition of the group and the personal characteristics of each person. Someone wears a T-shirt in winter and sleeps in the same sleeping bag, but someone in the summer will not hurt.

A month ago, I would have said that this is simply impossible for me, a mega-heat-loving creature. It was scary, I was waiting for the night with horror. Two foams under me, and below - only snow, a sleeping bag, thin cotton underwear: in my opinion, I should have frozen to death.

Morning has come:

I’ll tell you how it was, how, in principle, we settled down for the night, what secrets of winter sleep in nature I learned and all this, of course, will be accompanied by my photo illustrations.

Having found a worthy place for parking, the first thing the men began to put up was a tent that would protect us from the wind and we would spend the night in it.

To be honest, I had a vague idea of ​​how it would all turn out. Fantasy drew me a potbelly stove in the middle of the tent, everyone around was lying side by side, while under each there were ten foams plus three sleeping bags and on top - a couple more blankets. And most importantly, spend the night in outerwear and completely hiding with your head in your warm "house".

The reality turned out to be quite different.

After we fried the barbecue, had dinner and began to nod off, it was time to go to bed. To do this, they began to pitch ... tents in the tent!

At the bottom of each, they put one layer of household insulation (such a foam with foil) and one more foam each - ordinary, tourist, thick.

We were given a sleeping bag. ONE! I looked and realized that everything is the end for me.

The organizers strictly said - two things must be done, which seemed completely illogical to me, a beginner.

1. Strip down to thin clothing (such as thermal underwear)

2. Do not climb into the sleeping bag with your head and do not breathe there IN ANY EVENT!

Now I understand that everything was correct. And that's why.

1. While we were putting up tents, carrying things, etc., we were sweating and it became hot. When you lie down and stop moving, the body lowers the temperature and sweat (respectively - wet clothes) becomes icy, dampness appears in the sleeping bag and it will be simply unrealistic to warm up. Dry thin clothes warm the body, especially since we heat the air inside the sleeping bag with the same heat, creating a very comfortable microclimate.

2. When we get into the sleeping bag with our head and start breathing there, we exhale not only air into it, but also the moisture of our body. After a while, there will be such dampness inside that it will be unbearable to sleep from the dog's cold. Dryness is the key to warmth. If the face is cold, then it can be covered with something separately. For example, like me - a towel. A couple of hours later I was shocked - this very towel could be wrung out, it was so wet. And if I exhaled all this "inside", then my night would turn into hell.

In the photo, our assistant, a stove, is filled with gasoline and she blows warm air into the tent. Personally, my opinion is that it does not help much, except to keep the air dry.

In the morning I woke up with surprise - all night - as if killed, it was comfortable and ... WARM. Fantastic. It doesn’t happen like that ... but - it was! It seemed to me a miracle.

So nothing is impossible. We deprive ourselves of much of the pleasure of this wonderful life by our fears. The brush and paints are in our hands, it is quite possible to color everyday life.

This trip with Watermap completely shook my brain, pulled me out of my comfort zone, made me freer. This changes the mind, that's for sure.

Guess all of us have been in the off-season and winter hikes when at night, lying in a tent, only two questions are of concern: “Why is it so cold?” and “When will the morning come?” This situation is also possible in summer trips at high-altitude overnight stays. But a tourist is an inventive person and does not like to freeze, and therefore obvious and not very ways to keep warm in a tent began to appear. First, let's figure out when it's warm for us: 1 . In the sun or around a campfire. In this case, we are warmed by a third-party heat source. 2 . When we are wrapped up in warm clothes, a down jacket, a sleeping bag. In this case, thanks to good thermal insulation, we keep our own heat. It is on these two concepts (saving own heat and receiving heat from an external source) and on their combination that the methods of warming in a tent are built: Feet in backpack. After a cold snap, the limbs begin to freeze first. There's an easy way to prevent your feet from freezing - stuff them in an empty backpack. This will add an extra layer of thermal insulation and keep you much warmer. Fleece liner. During preparation, analyze the future region of the trip, if cold overnight stays are possible, and you are not sure about your sleeping bag, buy a fleece liner. The thing is not expensive, light and at the same time very warm. thermal underwear. A lot has already been written about thermal underwear, I will simply say - it should be. The only thing is that for sleep it is better to buy thermal underwear made from natural fibers, and not synthetics. Heating pad in the sleeping bag. The simplest heating pad on a hike is a bottle of hot water. If you are very cold, maybe two. They will keep you warm and the sleeping bag will keep you warm. Should be enough for the night. If the bottle cools down earlier, just pull it out of the sleeping bag. Sometimes a stone heated in a fire and wrapped in a cloth is used as a heating pad. The main thing is that it should not be too hot. Stitching, quilting, twine. This is a favorite way for young people. Two sleeping bags are fastened into one, where both tourists climb and warm one of them with their warmth! A very efficient way. In addition, it is also pleasant if you sleep with an individual of the opposite sex)) Sparka raises the comfort temperature by 7-10%. Tent heating. If you have a stove, candles or dry alcohol, you can heat the tent with their help. At the same time, be as careful as possible, because the tent burns down in a matter of seconds. In general, the presence of open flames in the tent is prohibited. But what can't you do when it's cold.. You can still warm the tent with a hot stone. We take a stone heated in a fire, put it in an iron bowl and carry it to the tent. A place should already be prepared in the tent - things have been removed, flooring from boards has been laid out at the bottom, because when the bowl gets very hot, it may well melt the carimate and the bottom of the tent. Toilet paper. A friend of mine took three rolls on a hike. toilet paper and every night he wrapped himself in it from head to toe. Says - helps, he did not try. The main disadvantage is that by morning the paper turns into crumbs and it takes a long time to clean things from it. We have warm nights!